A creditor in a crypto insolvency sits at an uncomfortable intersection: the assets are digital, often cross-border, and moving fast. Courts in England and Wales, the DIFC, Singapore, and Hong Kong have each developed workable tools – freezing orders, disclosure orders, proprietary claims – but the window for deploying them closes in hours, not weeks. This analysis maps what recent enforcement tells operators about their practical position and what a creditor must do, and do quickly, to protect a claim.
The central question for any creditor is whether the insolvent estate holds anything recoverable. In crypto insolvency that turns on two prior questions: whether the tokens are property capable of being claimed, and whether they still exist on-chain in a form accessible to the officeholder or to a claimant asserting a proprietary interest. Courts across the major common-law hubs have now answered the first question firmly in the affirmative. The second question is where the legal and operational work concentrates.
The sections below work through the legal basis for a creditor claim, the procedural weapons available, the cross-border dimension that almost every crypto insolvency raises, and the decision calculus operators should run before an insolvency event crystallizes – not after.
Are crypto tokens property a creditor can claim?
Digital tokens are recognized as property capable of supporting a proprietary claim in every major common-law insolvency forum. That consensus is the starting point for any creditor strategy. In England and Wales, the foundational analysis in AA v Persons Unknown [2019] established that cryptoassets satisfy the criteria for property rights. The Hong Kong Court of First Instance confirmed the same principle in Re Gatecoin [2023] HKCFI 914, and Singapore's High Court extended it to proprietary injunctive relief in CLM v CLN [2022] SGHC 46. The DIFC Courts have followed, with 2025 decisions granting worldwide freezing orders in support of foreign proceedings.
Property status matters in insolvency for two reasons. First, a creditor who can establish a proprietary interest – as distinct from a simple unsecured debt – may be able to claim specific assets outside the general distribution waterfall. Second, a proprietary claim supports the injunctive relief that freezes assets before the liquidator or a fraudulent counterparty can dissipate them.
The practical limit is tracing. A proprietary claim requires the claimant to show that its assets are still identifiable on-chain. Where tokens have been mixed, bridged across chains, or converted to a different asset, the tracing exercise grows complex. On-chain forensic analysis – using tools comparable to those operated by established blockchain analytics firms – is a prerequisite, not an optional supplement, to any serious proprietary claim in crypto insolvency.
Operators should therefore treat their transaction history, wallet addresses, and any recorded counterparty identifiers as core litigation evidence from the moment an insolvency is announced. That evidence degrades if exchanges clear records or if the relevant blockchain forks. The preservation obligation is immediate.
What happens to crypto tokens once insolvency proceedings open?
Once formal insolvency proceedings open, the officeholder – liquidator, administrator, or trustee, depending on the regime – takes control of the estate. Where the insolvent entity held tokens on behalf of customers, the central question is whether those tokens form part of the general estate or are held on trust for the customers whose assets they represent. That question turns on the terms of the contract between the platform and its users, and on the custody arrangements in place.
Platforms operating a pooled omnibus model, where user assets are commingled in platform wallets, present the hardest cases for individual creditors. The proprietary claim may exist in theory, but identifying the specific coins attributable to a specific creditor inside a pooled wallet is difficult without co-operation from the officeholder and access to the platform's internal ledger. In our cross-border practice, we have seen cases where that ledger was incomplete, exported in a format hostile to analysis, or subject to conflicting claims from multiple jurisdictions simultaneously.
By contrast, platforms operating genuine segregated custody – where each customer's assets sit in a dedicated wallet with private keys the platform never controls – present a cleaner picture. The customer retains a proprietary interest that survives the insolvency. The practical reality is that very few retail-oriented platforms operated true segregation before recent regulatory pressure under MiCA (Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation) and the VARA rulebooks compelled the point.
The creditor's first step on insolvency announcement is therefore forensic: determine the custody model, obtain the contractual terms, and commission an on-chain analysis to map wallet addresses to balances. This should occur within the first day or two of the insolvency filing. Officeholders are required under most insolvency regimes to preserve records, but that obligation does not substitute for independent evidence-gathering by the creditor.
How do freezing orders and disclosure orders work in crypto insolvency?
A freezing order (or Mareva injunction) prevents a respondent from disposing of assets up to the value of the claim. In England and Wales, a worldwide freezing order can reach assets held on exchanges anywhere in the world, provided the court has jurisdiction over the respondent. The DIFC Courts have granted equivalent relief, including in support of foreign proceedings, making them a powerful interim forum for creditors with UAE-nexus claims.
In a crypto insolvency, the more immediate tool is often a Norwich Pharmacal order or a Bankers Trust order – both disclosure instruments. A Norwich Pharmacal order compels a third party (typically an exchange) that has been mixed up in the relevant transfers to disclose the identity of the account holder behind a wallet address. A Bankers Trust order obtains account records to enable tracing. Both are available in England and Wales and have been applied to crypto exchanges in multiple recent decisions.
The critical operational point is that exchange compliance with these orders is time-sensitive. Accounts may be closed, assets withdrawn, and records archived in ways that make compliance partial. Applications for disclosure orders should be filed within days of identifying the relevant wallet addresses, not weeks. In our practice, we have seen disclosure applications filed several weeks after the relevant transfers that returned incomplete records because the exchange had by then purged the relevant account tier.
At the DIFC Courts, the 2025 decision in Trafigura v Gupta confirmed that a worldwide freezing order can be granted in support of foreign arbitral or court proceedings, extending the practical reach of DIFC interim relief considerably. This matters for operators with a Dubai nexus whose counterparties may hold assets in other jurisdictions.
Singapore's proprietary injunction jurisdiction was confirmed in CLM v CLN [2022] SGHC 46. Hong Kong's first tokenised injunction, issued in HCA 2417/2024, demonstrated the court's willingness to name wallet addresses rather than natural persons as respondents – a material development for claimants dealing with pseudonymous counterparties.
For a scoped assessment of your freezing-order options, the timeline and forum analysis turns on where your counterparty holds assets and where you can found jurisdiction quickly. Map your options – our disputes desk is available for urgent matters.
Can stablecoin issuers freeze tokens directly?
For claims involving stablecoins – particularly USDT and USDC – a parallel enforcement mechanism exists at the issuer level. Both Tether and Circle hold contract-level freeze and blacklist authority over their issued tokens. That authority allows them to immobilize specific wallet addresses, preventing any transfer of the frozen balance, without needing a court order in the first instance.
Issuers generally act on receipt of a law-enforcement case reference, an OFAC designation, or a court order from a recognized jurisdiction. The process is faster than litigation – in some cases, Tether has frozen wallets within hours of a documented request supported by the right credentials. The practical requirements are: a transaction hash or set of addresses identifying the funds, a professional forensic report establishing the nexus between those addresses and the theft or fraud, and either a law-enforcement referral or a court order.
This tool is not available for all assets. Bitcoin, Ether, and most non-stablecoin tokens cannot be frozen at protocol level by any issuer. For those assets, the only route is on-exchange immobilization through a court-ordered exchange freeze, which requires identifying where the tokens currently sit and moving faster than the person holding them.
In insolvency, stablecoin freezes are most relevant where the insolvent platform converted user assets to stablecoins in the period before collapse – a pattern observed in several exchange failures – or where pre-insolvency asset flight involved converting volatile assets to stablecoins for easier exit. Both fact patterns create an opportunity for creditors to move at issuer level in parallel with court proceedings.
Why does cross-border jurisdiction complicate every crypto insolvency claim?
Cross-border jurisdiction is not an edge case in crypto insolvency – it is the default. A typical failed exchange operates from one jurisdiction, holds user funds across multiple exchange wallets in a second, banks in a third, and faces creditors in a dozen more. The officeholder conducting the insolvency may be seated in a jurisdiction that has no direct relationship with the jurisdiction where the most valuable assets sit.
The recognition question matters immediately. English liquidation orders are recognized in many common-law jurisdictions. DIFC liquidation orders have a defined recognition pathway into mainland UAE courts and into a growing list of bilateral recognition arrangements. Singapore and Hong Kong share strong common-law pedigree. But in civil-law or non-treaty jurisdictions, recognition may require parallel local proceedings, which adds cost and time.
For creditors, the cross-border dimension raises a practical sequencing question: which forum to file in first. The answer generally turns on three factors. First, where are the most liquid assets? A frozen wallet on a major exchange is worth more than a judgment against a shell company. Second, which forum will move fastest? England and Wales, the DIFC, Singapore, and Hong Kong all offer emergency ex parte relief; other jurisdictions may require contested hearings. Third, where does the creditor have existing standing or a prior contractual nexus?
We regularly advise creditors on this forum-selection analysis in the first 24 to 48 hours after a collapse. In our experience, creditors who wait for the officeholder to act often find that the highest-value assets have moved, the exchange accounts have been closed, and the forum with the strongest jurisdiction is no longer viable on the available timeline.
Allied counsel in the relevant jurisdiction handle local filings where a parallel local proceeding is required. The co-ordination of those filings across time zones is an operational matter as much as a legal one. A written co-ordination protocol between counsel teams, agreed before any application is filed, reduces the risk of conflicting orders that create procedural complexity a well-resourced respondent can exploit.
Unsecured creditor vs. proprietary claimant: which position is stronger?
The distinction between an unsecured creditor and a proprietary claimant is the central strategic question in crypto insolvency litigation. An unsecured creditor proves a debt in the insolvency and receives a pro-rata distribution from whatever the officeholder recovers. In large exchange failures, that distribution has historically been cents on the dollar, after years of proceedings. A proprietary claimant, by contrast, asserts a right to specific identified assets ahead of the general distribution. If the claim succeeds, those assets are not available to other creditors at all.
Establishing a proprietary claim requires satisfying several conditions. The claimant must show a fiduciary relationship or an express trust, or must demonstrate that the assets transferred were held in circumstances that give rise to a constructive trust. The assets must be traceable to the claim. And in an insolvency, the claim must be recognized by the officeholder or established by court order before distribution begins.
A common assumption is that proprietary claims are straightforward where a platform said it held assets "in trust" in its terms of service. That assumption is dangerous. Courts look at conduct, not labels. A platform that pooled assets in omnibus wallets, used user funds to cover operational costs, or failed to maintain wallet-to-user ledger records may not satisfy a proprietary trust analysis regardless of what the terms of service state. Regulatory language in the terms, similarly, does not create a trust where the operational reality contradicts it.
The practical implication is that the strength of a proprietary claim must be assessed against the actual custody architecture, not the contractual language. In our cross-border practice, this assessment – gathering the platform's wallet records, on-chain data, and internal accounting – is the first analytical step, and it determines whether the litigation strategy is proprietary or unsecured.
Decision matrix: which approach fits which creditor profile?
Different creditor profiles require different approaches, and the window for choosing is narrow once insolvency opens.
Profile A – institutional creditor with large unsecured claim, clear transaction records. The priority is filing a proof of debt early, commissioning an on-chain forensic report in parallel, and assessing whether a proprietary trust argument is sustainable on the facts. If the proprietary analysis is strong, file for a freezing order in the most responsive forum before the officeholder completes the initial asset sweep. Timeline for filing: within 48 hours of the insolvency announcement if on-chain evidence supports it. Key risk: officeholder contests the proprietary claim and the general estate dilutes before the dispute is resolved.
Profile B – business creditor with a claim arising from a pre-insolvency fraudulent transfer. The focus is on setting aside the transfer under the applicable insolvency avoidance regime (preference, transaction at an undervalue, or equivalent). This is an officeholder action in most regimes, but creditors may apply to the court directly in some jurisdictions. A Norwich Pharmacal application against any exchange involved in the transfer is a parallel priority. Timeline for filing: the transfer-avoidance limitation period varies, but the forensic trail cools fast. Key risk: the recipient is offshore in a jurisdiction with limited insolvency co-operation, slowing enforcement.
Profile C – minority token holder or small creditor. A collective creditor action coordinated through the officeholder or through a creditor committee is almost always the efficient path. Individual litigation at this level is rarely cost-proportionate unless the claim involves a discrete identifiable transfer – in which case, a stablecoin issuer freeze may provide a low-cost first step. Timeline: join the creditor committee within the first meeting window. Key risk: committee is dominated by large creditors whose interests are not aligned.
Profile D – counterparty with a live contractual claim (e.g., unperformed trade, loan, or service agreement). The claim likely sits as unsecured. The priority is calculating and filing the proof of debt early, and assessing whether any collateral arrangement (pledge, lien, or set-off right) elevates part of the claim. Key risk: collateral arrangement is challenged by the officeholder as a preference if it was granted in the suspect period before insolvency.
Micro-matter: stablecoin recovery across two forums
In a recent matter, a fintech company discovered that a substantial stablecoin balance – held on a third-party exchange – had been transferred out of its account following a credential compromise at the platform level. The transfers, executed over a 48-hour window, routed funds through three intermediate wallets across two blockchains before arriving at addresses on a separate exchange in a different jurisdiction. We commenced an on-chain forensic analysis within hours of the discovery and filed for a disclosure order in a leading common-law forum the following morning, before the relevant exchange had processed the withdrawal requests pending on those wallets. The order was granted ex parte and served on the exchange within the same business day. A parallel stablecoin issuer freeze request was filed simultaneously, supported by the forensic report and a law-enforcement case reference obtained that afternoon. The issuer froze the relevant addresses within hours of receiving the request. By the time the affected exchange responded to the disclosure order, the funds were immobilized and the underlying account identity was documented. The matter proceeded to contested recovery proceedings in the second forum, supported by the frozen balance and the identity evidence.
The lesson is not that this outcome is guaranteed – it is that it was achievable only because every step was initiated within the first 24 hours. A delay of even two or three additional days would have resulted in completed withdrawals and a forensic trail cold enough to defeat the issuer freeze request on procedural grounds.
What do MiCA and VARA change for creditors in an operator insolvency?
For creditors of regulated operators, the recent wave of regulation under MiCA and the VARA rulebooks has changed the insolvency picture materially. Both regimes impose segregation obligations on licensed custodians and exchanges. A platform authorized under MiCA as a CASP (crypto-asset service provider) is required to keep client assets segregated from its own. The VARA rulebooks for custody and exchange activities impose comparable requirements. Where those obligations were honored, a creditor's proprietary claim is structurally stronger from the outset.
Regulators may also have conducted supervisory examinations of the licensed operator in the period before insolvency. Those examination records – where accessible – can be valuable evidence of whether the segregation obligations were actually met, or whether they existed on paper only. Under MiCA, ESMA and the national competent authorities have ongoing supervisory roles; their files may be obtainable in some insolvency proceedings through the officeholder or through regulatory disclosure channels.
MiCA also introduced the concept of a detailed white paper and disclosure regime for token issuers. Where a creditor holds tokens issued under MiCA, the white paper representations may give rise to a damages claim in addition to any insolvency proof – particularly where the issuer's reserve or redemption disclosures were misleading.
The VARA regime in Dubai has an additional dimension: the DIFC Courts operate as the de facto dispute resolution forum for claims against VARA-regulated entities, and the DIFC's insolvency regime – which draws on English common law – provides a familiar toolkit for common-law creditors. This cross-border coherence between the regulatory regime (VARA, mainland Dubai) and the judicial forum (DIFC Courts) is a structural advantage for creditors in UAE-nexus insolvencies.
If a prior recovery attempt stalled – or if a platform you work with is showing signs of distress – a second structural read can identify the route forward. Contact OBOLUS at info@oboluslaw.com or write to us at info@oboluslaw.com before the window closes. Map your options.
How do AML records and the Travel Rule create evidence for creditors?
The Travel Rule (the obligation, derived from FATF Recommendation 15, to pass originator and beneficiary data alongside a virtual-asset transfer) has created a new evidentiary resource for creditors. A regulated exchange that received funds from an insolvent platform or from a fraudulent transferor is required, under the Travel Rule, to have collected and retained the originator's identity data. That data is now obtainable through disclosure orders in most major forums.
AML records more broadly – customer due diligence files, transaction monitoring alerts, suspicious activity reports – sit on exchange compliance databases that courts have shown willingness to reach through Norwich Pharmacal and Bankers Trust orders. Where a transfer chain passed through multiple regulated exchanges, each hop has a compliance record. Following that chain through disclosure orders across jurisdictions is operationally intensive but has produced the decisive evidence in several high-value crypto fraud recoveries in our practice.
The implication for creditors is that AML compliance, a regulatory cost to operators, becomes a litigation asset for claimants. The better-regulated the exchange through which stolen or fraudulently transferred assets passed, the richer the evidentiary trail. Creditors filing disclosure applications should therefore prioritize exchanges subject to stringent AML regimes – FCA-registered, MAS-licensed, SFC-licensed, or VARA-authorized entities – because those exchanges carry the most complete compliance records and are most likely to comply promptly with a court order from a recognized forum.
What should operators do now, before any insolvency event?
Preparation before an insolvency event – whether as a potential creditor of a counterparty, or as an operator managing insolvency risk within the business – determines the quality of the options available when a crisis materializes.
On the creditor side, operators should know their position on every major platform they use: the custody model, the contractual terms, the jurisdiction of incorporation, and the insolvency regime that would govern a failure. That knowledge, documented and updated periodically, allows the first-day analysis to proceed in hours rather than days when an event occurs.
On the operator side, maintaining genuine asset segregation – not just contractual language asserting segregation, but wallet architecture and internal ledger records that a court could verify – is the single most important step for protecting both customers and the business itself in a wind-down scenario. Operators subject to MiCA or VARA are required to do this. Operators in lighter-touch jurisdictions should do it anyway, because the cross-border litigation environment increasingly penalizes the absence of it.
Counterparty risk assessment is also material. We regularly advise operators on the due diligence framework for exchange relationships: what to ask, what records to retain, and how to structure contractual protections that improve the creditor position in a counterparty insolvency. These are not complex instruments, but they are overlooked until it is too late to negotiate them.
Finally, incident response protocols – the internal procedures that govern what the team does in the first hours after discovering a theft, a fraud, or a counterparty failure – should be documented and tested. The legal tools described above work best when the instructing client arrives with transaction hashes, wallet addresses, and a clear account of the relevant timeline. Operators who arrive days later, after an internal investigation consumed the critical window, face materially reduced options.
Related at OBOLUS
- Disputes & Asset Recovery for Digital-Asset Businesses – our practice overview covering freezing relief, disclosure orders, and on-chain recovery across 25+ forums.
- Smart Contract Dispute Resolution in Panama – jurisdictional analysis of Panama's emerging legal treatment of smart-contract claims.
- Creditor Claims in Crypto Insolvency for Established Operators – scoped advisory service for operators facing a counterparty insolvency event.
FAQ
Can stolen crypto actually be recovered?
Recovery is possible but depends on speed, the assets involved, and the exchanges through which funds moved. Courts in England and Wales, Singapore, Hong Kong, and the DIFC have all granted proprietary relief over crypto. Stablecoin issuers can freeze balances at wallet level. For other tokens, on-exchange freezes obtained through court orders are the primary tool. The earlier the legal action, the higher the recovery probability – delays of more than a few days materially reduce viable options.
How fast must I act after a digital-asset theft?
Action within the first 24 to 48 hours is critical. On-chain forensic analysis should begin immediately to identify wallet addresses and trace movement. Disclosure applications against exchanges should be filed within the first working day where the evidence supports it. Stablecoin issuer freeze requests require a forensic report and, in most cases, a law-enforcement reference – both obtainable quickly with the right support. Every additional day the funds remain unfrozen increases the risk of completed withdrawal or further obfuscation.
Can a court freeze assets held on an exchange?
Yes. Courts in England and Wales routinely grant freezing orders that bind exchanges as third parties, preventing withdrawal of identified balances. The DIFC Courts, Singapore, and Hong Kong have granted equivalent relief. A Norwich Pharmacal or Bankers Trust order can compel an exchange to disclose account identity and transaction records. Compliance from well-regulated exchanges – those licensed under the FCA, MAS, SFC, or VARA regimes – is generally prompt once a recognized court order is served.
OBOLUS is an independent digital-asset law boutique acting only for businesses. We advise exchanges, custodians, token issuers, and funds on disputes and on-chain asset recovery across more than 25 forums, and on the licensing, banking, and compliance that sit around them. Digital assets are the whole of our practice. We move for freezing relief and exchange disclosure while the trail is live – and we co-ordinate allied counsel across jurisdictions when parallel filings are required. To discuss a recovery or insolvency situation, contact info@oboluslaw.com or email us at info@oboluslaw.com.
By Glen Sorensen, Disputes & Recovery Analyst – specializing in cross-border crypto asset recovery, freezing relief, and creditor strategy in digital-asset insolvency proceedings.
This publication is general information about the law and does not constitute legal advice. It is not a substitute for advice tailored to your circumstances. OBOLUS accepts no liability for action taken or not taken on the basis of this material. For advice on your situation, contact info@oboluslaw.com.